Why combine soilless growing with a greenhouse
Hydroponics grows plants in a nutrient solution instead of soil. Aquaponics adds fish to the loop, so their waste becomes the plants’ food. Putting either inside a greenhouse protects the equipment from weather, helps keep water and air temperatures steadier, and lets you grow beyond the outdoor season. The trade-off is added complexity: you now have to manage plumbing, electricity and water chemistry alongside the climate. If you are still deciding whether to build a greenhouse at all, see do I need a greenhouse?.
Hydroponic system types
Most home systems fall into a few families:
- Deep water culture (DWC): Plants sit in net pots with their roots in an aerated tank of nutrient solution. It is simple and popular for lettuce and herbs.
- Nutrient film technique (NFT): A thin stream of solution runs along shallow channels past the roots. It suits leafy crops and small plants.
- Drip systems and Dutch buckets: Solution is dripped onto plants in a medium such as perlite or coconut coir. This suits larger fruiting crops such as tomatoes, peppers and cucumbers.
- Ebb and flow (flood and drain): A tray is periodically flooded and drained.
- Wicking and Kratky methods: Passive systems with no pump, useful for small experiments.
For a step-by-step starter build, see how to build a hydroponic garden.
Aquaponics basics
An aquaponic system links a fish tank to grow beds. Fish waste contains ammonia, which beneficial bacteria convert first to nitrite and then to nitrate, a form plants can use. The plants take up the nitrate and help clean the water before it returns to the fish. This biological cycle has to be established before the system is fully stocked, a process often called cycling that can take several weeks.
Common aquaponic layouts include media-filled grow beds, floating raft beds and NFT channels. Species choice depends on local regulations and the temperatures you can maintain. Tilapia, catfish and goldfish are frequently mentioned, but check what is legal to keep in your area.
Aquaponics is more demanding than hydroponics, and it is worth reading our overview of the downsides of aquaponics before committing.
Greenhouse design considerations
- Site and orientation: Choose a level, sunny spot with good drainage. Water is heavy, so the floor and base must support tanks and beds. See greenhouse base and foundation options and the best floor for a greenhouse.
- Size: Give yourself space to walk around tanks and beds, and allow for future expansion. A bigger water volume is generally more stable than a small one.
- Temperature: Nutrient solution that gets too warm holds less oxygen and encourages algae and root problems, while very cold solution slows growth. Aquaponics fish have their own temperature ranges. Insulating tanks and shading the greenhouse in summer helps. See greenhouse shade cloth.
- Ventilation and humidity: Open water surfaces add humidity, so plan for roof vents, side vents and possibly fans. See how to control humidity in a greenhouse.
- Light: Place tall crops where they will not shade shorter ones. In low-light seasons, supplemental lighting may be worthwhile.
- Water and drainage: Provide a clean water supply, an easy way to drain tanks, and a plan for where waste water goes.
- Electricity and safety: Pumps and air pumps need power. Use outdoor-rated equipment and residual current (GFCI/RCD) protection, and have an electrician check anything near water.
- Backup: In aquaponics especially, a power cut can quickly cause problems for fish. A battery backup air pump or generator is often recommended. For off-grid power for small loads such as pumps, see do solar panels work in greenhouses.
- Light-proof reservoirs: Opaque tanks and channels reduce algae growth.
A simple DIY approach
For hydroponics, start with a small DWC or NFT system for lettuce and herbs inside the greenhouse, and learn to manage nutrient strength and pH. For aquaponics, begin with a small, modest system and fish suited to your climate, cycle it patiently, and increase the size only after you understand the routine. Many people find it easier to start hydroponics first and move to aquaponics later.
What to grow
Leafy greens, herbs and basil are the easiest. Strawberries also do well in several soilless systems; see growing strawberries in a greenhouse. Larger crops such as tomatoes and cucumbers can be grown with drip systems or Dutch buckets, but they need strong support and careful feeding. Root vegetables generally suit soilless systems less well.
Can you use a fish tank for hydroponics?
A fish tank can be used as the basis of a small aquaponic set-up, with plants growing above the tank and taking up nutrients from the water. For pure hydroponics, a clear aquarium is not ideal because light encourages algae, so it is better to use opaque containers or cover the tank.
Do house plants work in hydroponics?
Many common house plants, such as pothos, philodendron and spider plants, can be grown with their roots in water or in a hydroponic medium, which is a low-cost way to experiment.
Cost and complexity
Expect higher start-up costs and more regular monitoring than soil gardening. Equipment can fail, and mistakes can affect an entire crop quickly. Keep notes, test water regularly and start small.