Short answer
A high tunnel is a tall, usually unheated, plastic-covered hoop structure that protects crops growing in the ground. A greenhouse is generally a more fully enclosed structure, often glazed with glass or rigid panels, that is designed to be heated, cooled and ventilated more precisely. The line between them is blurry, and in practice the main differences are the covering, how much climate control you add, and the price.
What a high tunnel is
A high tunnel is a walk-in tunnel made from a row of metal hoops covered with one or two layers of polythene film. It is tall enough to stand in, with doors at the ends and often roll-up sides for ventilation. Crops are usually grown straight in the soil.
High tunnels are meant to extend the growing season at both ends, protect crops from rain, wind and light frost, and warm the air and soil using the sun. They normally have little or no heating.
The names vary by country. In the UK they are commonly called polytunnels, in North America people say high tunnels or hoop houses. The structures are very similar. See polytunnels as a cheap greenhouse alternative for buying advice.
What a greenhouse is
A greenhouse is a more permanent, enclosed structure with a frame glazed with glass, polycarbonate or sometimes film. Most have a pitched or curved roof with roof vents, and many are designed to take heating, cooling fans, shading, benches and automatic vent openers. Plants are often grown in pots or on benches, though in-ground beds are possible.
For more on shapes, see types of greenhouses.
Side-by-side comparison
| High tunnel | Greenhouse | |
|---|---|---|
| Covering | Polythene film | Glass, polycarbonate or film |
| Frame | Bent steel hoops | Aluminium, steel or timber frame |
| Heating | Usually none | Often available |
| Climate control | Basic, mostly vents or roll-up sides | More options (vents, fans, heaters, shading) |
| Growing method | Mostly in the ground | In ground, pots or benches |
| Cost | Generally lower | Generally higher |
| Build time | Quick | Longer |
| Site | Can often cope with gentle slopes | Typically needs a level base |
| Permanence | Often semi-permanent, can be moved | More permanent |
| Appearance | Utilitarian | Often more decorative |
Cost and building
Tunnels use fewer parts and cheaper cover, so they tend to cost less for the same floor area and go up faster. Greenhouses cost more but last longer and often look better. For very small sizes, a small greenhouse kit and a small tunnel may be priced similarly. Exact costs depend on size, quality and region, so get several quotes.
Heating and climate control
Most high tunnels rely on the sun alone, which means they stay a bit warmer than the outside air but offer limited frost protection on very cold nights. Adding a second layer of film or fleece can help. Greenhouses can be heated, and glass and twin-wall polycarbonate hold heat better than a single layer of film. If winter growing is your goal, see cold vs heated greenhouses.
Growing in the ground vs in pots
Tunnels are often used for long rows of vegetables in the soil, such as tomatoes, salad crops and root vegetables. Greenhouses are popular for seed starting, pots, benches and tender ornamentals, though they can also hold in-ground beds.
Weather, durability and ventilation
- Weather. A film-covered tunnel can be damaged by strong wind or heavy snow if it is poorly anchored or not cleared. A glazed greenhouse is generally more resilient, though glass can break.
- Cover lifespan. Film usually needs replacement after several years. Glass can last much longer.
- Ventilation. Greenhouses usually have more options for vents and automatic openers. Tunnels rely on end doors and roll-up sides, which work well when well designed, and poorly when not.
- Condensation and shading. Tunnels can suffer from drips, though anti-drip film helps. Shading is harder on film, so you may need shade netting.
Which should you choose?
- Choose a high tunnel if you want the most growing area for the money, mainly grow crops in the soil, and mostly want season extension.
- Choose a greenhouse if you want better heat retention, a more permanent and attractive building, and options for benches, heating and propagation.
- Consider something smaller if you only need to harden off plants or protect a few crops: see cold frame vs greenhouse.