Short answer
A cold frame is a low, unheated box with a transparent lid that sits over a patch of soil. A greenhouse is a larger structure you can walk into. A cold frame is a cheap way to harden off seedlings and extend the season for hardy crops. A greenhouse gives more space, more control and the option to grow warm-season crops and work inside in any weather.
What a cold frame is
A cold frame is typically a bottomless box, made from wood, metal, plastic or brick, with a sloping lid made of glass, polycarbonate or clear plastic. It sits directly on the ground over a bed or on a prepared base. The sun warms the soil and air inside, and the walls and lid hold some of that warmth. There is no heating, so it relies on the sun and the soil’s own warmth.
Cold frames come in several forms:
- Fixed or permanent, built into the garden bed.
- Portable, lightweight units you can move as needed.
- Temporary, made from bales, old windows or simple frames for short-term use.
What a greenhouse is
A greenhouse is a walk-in structure with glazed walls and a roof, designed to hold plants at a more controlled temperature. It usually has vents, doors, benches and sometimes heating, shading and automatic watering. See types of greenhouses for the main shapes.
Comparison
| Cold frame | Greenhouse | |
|---|---|---|
| Size | Low, small footprint | Walk-in |
| Access | Reach in from above, bend down | Stand and work inside |
| Heating | None, passive solar only | Optional |
| Temperature gain | Modest, a few degrees above outside air depending on conditions | Larger, more controllable |
| Cost | Low | Moderate to high |
| Setup | Quick, often DIY | More involved |
| Upkeep | Minimal | Higher |
| Best crops | Hardy greens, seedlings, young plants | Tomatoes, cucumbers, peppers, tender plants, seedlings |
What a cold frame does well
- Hardening off. Move seedlings from indoors into a cold frame for a gradual introduction to outdoor conditions before planting out.
- Extending the season. Hardy salad leaves, spinach, kale and root crops can be sown earlier or harvested later.
- Protecting overwintering plants. Pots of hardy perennials, alpine plants and bulbs can be protected from wet and hard frost.
- Starting early crops. Radishes, lettuce and similar crops can be sown under cover in late winter in many climates.
- Small spaces. Fits on a patio, allotment or small bed.
What a greenhouse does better
- Warm-season crops. Tomatoes, peppers, cucumbers and aubergines need more height and warmth than a cold frame provides.
- More headroom and working space. You can stand up, store tools and set up benches.
- Year-round use. With a bit of heating or insulation, it can be used in winter. See cold vs heated greenhouses.
- Greater control. Vents, shade and heating give more options.
- Seed starting at scale. More room for trays.
Using a cold frame well
- Vent on sunny days. Even in winter, a closed frame can overheat quickly. Prop the lid open when the sun is out, and close it in the afternoon before the temperature falls.
- Insulate for cold nights. Cover the lid with an old blanket, sacking, straw mats or similar, and bank soil or straw around the sides.
- Position for sun. Face the lid toward the sun, ideally the south in the northern hemisphere. Sloping the lid helps rain run off and catches more light.
- Water carefully. Plants use less water in cold weather, and excess moisture can lead to disease.
- Watch for pests. Slugs and rodents sometimes shelter in the warmth.
- Secure the lid. Wind can lift and break a light lid.
Using both
Many gardeners find the two work well together. A cold frame can free up greenhouse space for tender plants by taking over hardening off and hardy crops. It can also be a first step if you are not sure you will use a greenhouse.
Which should you choose?
- Choose a cold frame if you have little space or money, mainly grow hardy crops, or need somewhere to harden off plants.
- Choose a greenhouse if you want to grow tall, warm-season crops, work under cover or garden through winter.
- Consider a tunnel if you want much more room for less money than a greenhouse: see polytunnels and high tunnel vs greenhouse.