Short answer
A cold (unheated) greenhouse relies on the sun and can grow hardy crops, seedlings and some overwintering plants. A frost-free greenhouse has a small amount of heat to keep temperatures just above freezing, which protects tender plants. A fully heated greenhouse maintains warmer conditions, allowing tropical plants and winter production, at higher running costs.
What counts as cold, frost-free and heated
There are no strict official categories, but gardeners commonly use these:
- Cold greenhouse. No added heat. Temperatures inside are usually a few degrees warmer than outdoors on sunny days, but on clear, cold nights it can drop close to the outside temperature.
- Frost-free (cool) greenhouse. A small heater with a thermostat keeps the temperature above freezing, often with a target of roughly 5°C (about 40°F), though the right setting depends on the plants.
- Heated (warm) greenhouse. Maintains considerably higher temperatures, which is needed for tropical plants, early heat-loving crops and winter growing. The higher the target, the higher the energy use.
What you can grow in a cold greenhouse
With no heat, you can generally grow plants that tolerate cold, or use the greenhouse for the part of the year when frosts are not a concern:
- Cool-season vegetables. Lettuce, spinach, rocket (arugula), kale, chard, radishes, spring onions and similar crops, especially in autumn and early spring.
- Hardy herbs. Parsley, chives, coriander (cilantro) and mint.
- Seed starting and hardening off. Early sowings of hardy plants, and acclimatising seedlings before planting out.
- Summer crops after the last frost. Tomatoes, cucumbers and peppers, planted after the frost risk has passed, benefit from the extra warmth.
- Overwintering hardy plants. Many alpines, pots of hardy perennials and bulbs are happier protected from winter wet.
A cold greenhouse extends the season but will not necessarily protect against hard frosts. In severe cold, extra protection such as fleece or bubble wrap can help.
Frost-free greenhouse
A little heat opens up more options:
- Tender perennials. Pelargoniums (geraniums), fuchsias, salvias and similar plants can survive winter.
- Citrus and other tender fruit trees. Many can be kept above freezing in pots. See can trees be grown in greenhouses.
- Early seed sowing. You can start some crops earlier, though germination of heat-loving seeds may still need extra warmth.
- Winter salads. Plants grow slowly in short days but stay alive and harvestable.
Fully heated greenhouse
With a higher minimum temperature you can try:
- Tropical and subtropical plants. Orchids, bananas, and many exotic foliage plants.
- Heat-loving crops early or late. Tomatoes, peppers and aubergines started early or extended into autumn.
- Propagation. Cuttings and seedlings that need steady warmth.
- Year-round production. Possible for some crops, though winter light levels can limit growth even with heat, and some growers add grow lights. See what are greenhouse crops.
Comparison
| Cold | Frost-free | Heated | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Heat source | Sun only | Small thermostat heater | Larger heater or system |
| Running cost | None | Low to moderate | Moderate to high |
| Typical use | Hardy crops, seedlings, season extension | Tender perennials, overwintering | Tropicals, early and winter crops |
| Risk in a hard freeze | High | Moderate (if heater fails) | Lower (if heater is adequate) |
Keeping heating costs down
- Insulate first. Better glazing, such as twin-wall polycarbonate, holds more heat than single glass, and sealing gaps stops drafts. See polycarbonate disadvantages for what to watch for.
- Add a second layer. Bubble wrap or horticultural film on the inside of the glazing is a common way to cut heat loss. Leave vents clear where needed.
- Heat a smaller zone. Divide the greenhouse or fit a plant tent over tender plants.
- Use thermal mass. Water barrels and stone absorb heat during the day and release it at night.
- Keep air moving. A small circulation fan spreads warmth evenly and reduces damp, which helps prevent disease.
- Be careful with ventilation. Opening vents wide can dump heat and shock plants, so ventilate in short bursts on cold days.
- Use a thermostat. It avoids wasted energy.
- Choose a design that suits. Earth-sheltered options such as sun pit greenhouses or bioshelters are designed to reduce heating needs.
- Shelter the site. A windbreak on the cold side cuts heat loss.
If you only need a little protection, a cold frame may be enough.
Heater safety
- Use heaters designed for greenhouses, with a thermostat, and follow the instructions.
- Fuel-burning heaters, such as paraffin or gas, produce moisture and fumes and need ventilation. Carbon monoxide is dangerous, so do not use unvented combustion heaters in a closed space where people spend time, and consider a carbon monoxide alarm.
- Electrical equipment in a damp greenhouse should be installed by a qualified electrician and protected by an RCD or GFCI.
- Keep heaters away from plants, plastic and dry materials.
Which should you choose?
If you mostly want to start seeds, grow salad and extend the season, a cold greenhouse is fine and costs nothing to run. If you want to keep tender plants alive through winter, a frost-free setup is a good middle path. If your goal is tropical plants or year-round heat-loving crops, plan for a proper heated greenhouse and the energy costs that come with it. For design options, see types of greenhouses.